Karolyn Englehardt: The Untold Story of Pete Rose’s First Wife

Karolyn Englehardt became known during Pete Rose’s career with the Cincinnati Reds, while also building her own career and family life. Born on March 14, 1942, in Cincinnati, Ohio, she was part of the Cincinnati baseball community during Pete Rose’s career while also establishing herself as a media personality and community leader.

After her marriage to Pete Rose ended, she focused on building an independent life and career while raising her children. As the unofficial leader of Cincinnati Reds wives during the Big Red Machine era, she created lasting impact in the baseball community before forging her own path as a single mother and businesswoman.

Karolyn Englehardt Quick Bio/Wiki

FactsDetails
Full NameKarolyn Ann Englehardt
BornMarch 14, 1942, Cincinnati, Ohio
Marriage to Pete RoseJanuary 25, 1964 – July 1980
ChildrenFawn Rose (1964), Pete Rose Jr. (1969)
Current PartnerBill Tyra (20+ years)
Notable RoleFirst Lady of Cincinnati Baseball

Early Life and Cincinnati Roots

Karolyn Ann Englehardt grew up in a modest household in Cincinnati, Ohio during the 1940s and 1950s. Her family embraced traditional mid-20th-century American values centered on community bonds. While she maintains privacy about her childhood, her Cincinnati roots proved essential to her future role in baseball history.

Growing up in the same city where Pete Rose would become a legend created the setting for their eventual meeting. The strong community values from her youth later helped her navigate challenges as a baseball wife and single mother.

Meeting Pete Rose: A Cincinnati Love Story

Karolyn Englehardt Meeting Pete Rose: A Cincinnati Love Story
Karolyn Englehardt kisses Pete Rose celebrating his 1975 Sports Illustrated award. | Source: SI

Summer 1963 changed everything when Karolyn met Pete Rose through a mutual friend at horse race tracks in Cincinnati as reported by The Cinema Holic. Their courtship moved quickly, with Pete already showing promise as a young Cincinnati Reds player. The racing tracks where they met became symbolic of the risks their relationship would represent.

Their shared hometown connection and Pete’s growing baseball reputation created an immediate bond. The attraction was intense enough to lead to engagement within months of meeting.

Building a Family During Baseball’s Golden Era

According to Times Now, Karolyn and Pete Rose married on January 25, 1964, at St. William’s Church in Cincinnati. The ceremony revealed early tension when Pete grew impatient during the Catholic service. “I’ll never forget it because I can still hear Pete saying, ‘Well, are we married yet?’ Because he wasn’t Catholic. Monsignor Sherry said, ‘Pete, I’ll tell you when you’re married, OK?'” Karolyn recalled in a 2012 Cincinnati interview.

Fawn Rose arrived in 1964, followed by Pete Rose Jr. in 1969. As Pete’s career flourished, Karolyn embraced motherhood while supporting the team that would become the Big Red Machine.

Read Also: Glena Goranson: The Woman Behind NFL Legend Pete Carroll

Karolyn Englehardt’s Role as The First Lady of Cincinnati Baseball

During the 1970s Big Red Machine era, Karolyn became the unofficial leader among Reds wives. Her organizational skills made her indispensable to the team’s extended family. As noted in her 2012 Cincinnati profile, “Who was it that took care of the new Reds wives? Who knew where all the child care, doctors and dentists were in Cincinnati? Who took charge of the wives’ hotel rooms and airline tickets for road trips?” according to her 2012 Cincinnati profile.

She served as mentor and problem-solver for other baseball wives navigating the sport’s unique challenges. Her knowledge of baseball operations rivaled many insiders, earning respect throughout the Cincinnati baseball community.

Media Career and Public Persona

Karolyn built her own media presence beyond her role as a baseball wife. She hosted a radio show on WNOP-AM (740) and, according to Cincinnati.com, became recognized as the city’s “first woman sportscaster.” Her broadcasting work gave her independence separate from Pete’s career.

Television appearances on shows hosted by Ruth Lyons and Paul Dixon showcased her personality to local audiences. She also appeared as a celebrity referee at professional wrestling events, including matches featuring Bobo Brazil and The Sheik, where blood once splattered onto her pants during a particularly violent match.

Memorable Moments and Baseball Anecdotes

Karolyn’s colorful personality shone through countless stories from the Big Red Machine years. She was known for her distinctive presence in Cincinnati, often drawing attention in public places.

Her distinctive voice became legendary. “I’ll answer the phone sometimes and say hello and they’ll say, ‘Mr. Rose?’ And I’ll say, ‘NO! It’s MRS. Rose!’ That’s me, I’ve always had this big mouth,” she told Cincinnati.com

Travel mishaps added to her charm, including boarding the wrong bus while pregnant during the 1969 All-Star Game in Washington, D.C. She actively supported the Reds during the 1975 World Series, becoming well known among fans for her spirited enthusiasm.

The Unraveling: Infidelity and Marriage Struggles

The marriage faced difficulties in its later years, ultimately leading to separation. Karolyn later shared that her decision to seek divorce was motivated by a desire to provide moral guidance and stability for her children. 

“I didn’t divorce Pete because I didn’t love him. I divorced Pete because I didn’t want my kids to say, ‘I guess we could (cheat on a spouse), Dad did it,'” she explained in an interview.

Karolyn Englehardt Divorce and New Independence

The Rose marriage ended in July 1980 after 16 years, attracting significant media attention as per New York Post. Karolyn handled the scrutiny with dignity, refusing to engage in public battles. She saw the divorce as an opportunity to reclaim independence and build life on her own terms.

The transition from baseball royalty to single mother required immense strength. She focused on practical matters and creating stability for Fawn and Pete Jr. while maintaining the leadership qualities she had shown among baseball wives.

Read More: Lupe Marinez Izzo: The Woman Behind Michigan State’s Basketball Legacy

Single Motherhood and Career Building

Karolyn Englehardt Single Motherhood and Career Building
Pete Rose plays pool with first wife Karolyn and children at Cincinnati home. | Source: Alamy

After divorce, Karolyn stepped away from the public spotlight to focus on raising her children. “Tired of her husband’s womanizing and inattention to his family, Karolyn threw herself even deeper into the lives of her beloved children, Fawn and Pete Jr.,” reported Cincinnati.com.

She pursued careers in real estate and business, achieving financial independence crucial for family stability. “My life was always around my kids. I was a mother and a father, let’s face it,” she acknowledged and describing the reality of single parenthood during Pete Jr.’s athletic development.

Family Legacy: Children and Grandchildren

Fawn Rose now lives in Seattle with 5-year-old twins Eden and Jude, who speak Spanish and Italian. Pete Rose Jr. manages a Chicago White Sox rookie league team and has two children: 7-year-old Peter Edward “P.J.” Rose III and 5-year-old Isabella (People).

Both children maintain strong relationships with their mother while navigating complex dynamics with their famous father. Karolyn’s parenting emphasized stability and moral clarity, providing foundation that serves her children well into adulthood.

A Painful Return: Pete Jr.’s Major League Debut

September 1, 1997, brought mixed emotions when Pete Jr. debuted with the Cincinnati Reds, going 1-for-3. Seating arrangements revealed ongoing family tensions when Pete Sr. received dugout seats while Karolyn sat elsewhere. “I was hurt when Pete (Sr.) came in and they gave him seats right by the dugout, I think, and my tickets were somewhere else,” she told Cincinnati.com.

Marty Brennaman showed kindness by sharing his seats. “I’ll never forget, and I love him to death to this day, Marty Brennaman gave me his four seats that he had for that game,” she remembered. This gesture highlighted the respect Karolyn earned throughout the baseball community.

Health Challenges and Adaptation

Karolyn faces mobility challenges requiring lifestyle adjustments. she explained: “A knee replacement in ’07, and it still bothers me, the left one. And now my back, my fourth and fifth vertebrae shifts on my sciatic nerve so I can’t stand long, so they got me a scooter.”

She shops at “Meijer’s, Kroger’s, Wal-Mart and Sam’s because they have scooters. And Jo-Ann’s Fabric,” showing practical adaptation to maintain independence.

Finding Love Again: Life with Bill Tyra

Bill Tyra, who “was Petey’s coach for Tyra Trucking,” has been Karolyn’s partner for over 20 years. “I’ve been with him 20 years, and any day I’m going to say yes. He’s a good guy,” she shared with Cincinnati.com in 2012.

Their relationship provides the stability missing from her first marriage. “I’m still a happy person. I think I’m content… I don’t have to worry where my husband is,” she reflected, capturing the peace of a trustworthy partnership.

Read Also: Katarina Miketin: Entrepreneur, Model, and NFL Coach’s Mike Zimmer Fiance

Karolyn Englehardt Last Contact with Pete Rose

Karolyn Englehardt Last Contact with Pete Rose
Karolyn Rose with children Pete Jr. and Fawn celebrating baseball milestone moment. | Source: Getty Images

Karolyn’s final interaction with Pete Rose occurred at Pete Jr.’s wedding nearly two decades ago. “Pete came to the wedding. I was in the church down at St. Xavier and he walked up and said, ‘Hello … um, hi.’ That was the extent of it,” she told Cincinnati.com.

This brief exchange at their son’s wedding represents their complete separation despite sharing children and grandchildren.

Perspective on Forgiveness and Moving Forward

Karolyn’s approach to forgiveness reflects hard-earned wisdom. She reflected: “Forgive him? I never hated anyone, that’s not the way I work. I don’t care who it was that did something to me. Maybe I should have hated Pete, but no. I have to say that I forgive him.”

She also observed Pete’s different treatment of his families: “(Pete) is better to his second family’s kids than he was to his own kids. And my kids never asked him for anything.” When Carol Woliung faced divorce from Pete, Karolyn commented: “This woman, I feel sorry for her. Me, I’m saying I feel sorry for her. But I still say what comes around goes around.”

Current Life and Contentment

As of 2025, Karolyn Englehardt lives quietly in Cincinnati with Bill Tyra, focusing on family and community service. She continues charitable work, including knitting “scarves for the homeless,” according to the interview. Her routine includes shopping trips using mobility scooters and staying connected with grandchildren in Seattle and Chicago.

The contentment she has found contrasts sharply with her turbulent years as Pete Rose’s wife. Her current life represents the peace and stability she always sought.

Legacy and Reflection

Karolyn Englehardt’s legacy extends beyond her connection to Pete Rose. She pioneered women’s roles in Cincinnati sports media as the city’s first female sportscaster. Her leadership among baseball wives during the Big Red Machine era created support systems that strengthened the entire organization.

Following Pete Rose’s death in September 2024, her story reminds us of the human cost behind sports legends. Her journey from scandal to stability offers inspiration for anyone rebuilding after betrayal. The woman who once organized World Series travel now finds victory in forgiveness, family bonds, and personal peace.

You may like it: Kelsey Holmer: Ohio Educator Becomes Eagles Star Lane Johnson’s Fiancée

FAQ’s About Karolyn Englehardt

Q: When did Karolyn Englehardt marry Pete Rose?

January 25, 1964, at St. William’s Church in Cincinnati.

Q: How many children do they have? 

Two children: Fawn Rose (1964) and Pete Rose Jr. (1969).

Q: What was her role with the Cincinnati Reds? 

Unofficial leader of Reds wives, organizing travel, childcare, and team support.

Q: Did she have her own career? 

Yes, radio host on WNOP-AM (740) and Cincinnati’s first woman sportscaster.

Q: When did they divorce? 

July 1980 after 16 years of marriage.

Q: Who is she with now? 

Bill Tyra, her partner of 20+ years and former coach of Pete Jr.

Q: How many grandchildren does she have?

Four: Eden, Jude, P.J., and Isabella.

Leave a Comment